Maybe better in Scotland
Geoff: Nup. No good. This beer is the weakest link. Goodbye. Rating: 2 stars.
Oliver wasn't quite so harsh: A lovely copper color and a sweet, malty nose. It's not particularly bitter, so India Pale Ale is probably somewhat of a misnoma. Head clings all the way down the glass. Maybe a tad watery. In its defence, this bottle was dusty when I bought it from Dan Murphy's in East Malvern, Melbourne, so I suspect it was not particularly fresh. Perhaps I should travel to Scotland and try it closer to the brewery! Rating: 2.5.